Search

  • "Pay or Okay": 1,500 € a year for your online privacy?

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    Should “Pay or Okay” be legitimised for Meta, companies across all industries could follow its lead. But what’s the current situation in the member states?
    … risk. After the European Court of Justice (CJEU) declared Meta’s handling of user data illegal  in July 2023, Meta switched to a “Pay or Okay” system to once again bypass … “Pay or Okay”. If the EDPB legitimises the approach for Meta, more and more companies will follow the example and …
  • 28 NGOs urge EU DPAs to reject “Pay or Okay” on Meta

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) will soon issue what is likely to be its most significant opinion to date
    … Board DPA’s request for an EDPB opinion on “consent or pay” Meta says “pay for your rights”. After the European Court of Justice (CJEU) declared Meta’s handling of user data illegal last July, Meta jumped to the next best option to bypass the GDPR and …
  • Meta ignores the users’ right to easily withdraw consent

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    If Instagram and Facebook users want to withdraw their consent, they have to buy an expensive subscription
    … 100 … Complaint against Meta on the withdrawal issue (EN) Previous complaint … relating to the consent phase (EN – Machine translation) Meta’s latest attempt to circumvent EU privacy laws. It has … since the European Court of Justice (CJEU) ruled that Meta’s handling of user data was illegal . Yet the social …
  • noyb files GDPR complaint against Meta over “Pay or Okay”

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    Meta charges up to €251.88 to respect the fundamental right to privacy of EU users. This is a violation of the GDPR
    … The European Court of Justice (CJEU) ruled in July that Meta’s handling of user data for personalized ads was … that: In January, the European Data Protection Board fined Meta €390 million for this violation and ordered the company … from 2018 . In its next attempt to undermine EU law, Meta now wants to charge people for choosing a …
  • Address trader sues German DPA to prevent noyb from accessing files

     / article  / 
    Credit Scoring
    noyb asked the Hessian authority for access to the case file of the Acxiom complaint. The address trader filed an interim injunction against the authority
    … of people and works with international clients such as Meta, Adobe, Google, IBM and PayPal. noyb will not back down …
  • Meta (Facebook / Instagram) to move to a "Pay for your Rights" approach

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    In order to bypass the GDPR, Meta apparently plans to move to a "Pay for your Rights" approach
    … 100 … Meta (Facebook / Instagram) to move to a "Pay for your Rights" approach The Wall Street Journal reported that Meta plans to move to a "Pay for your Rights" model, where … such as Instagram and Facebook. History has shown that Meta's regulator, the Irish DPC, is likely to agree to any …
  • Annual Report 2022 out now!

     / article
    2022 was the year of major decisions in our long-standing cases on EU-US data
    transfers
    … its draft decision on our “forced consent” case against Meta from 2018, which resulted in a fine of € 390 Million …
  • 23 years of illegal data transfers due to inactive DPAs and new EU-US deals

     / article  / 
    Data Transfers
    A new noyb analysis now shows how a combination of inactive DPAs and a new deal by the EU Commission lead to 23 years of privacy violations
    … using services like Google Analytics or tracking tools by Meta which entail unlawful data transfers to the USA. A new … to forward data about their visitors to Google and Meta servers in the United States. Despite explicit … (DPC) – so the supervisory authority for Google and Meta – is one of the 20 DPAs that have not yet lifted a …
  • 5 years of litigation: Meta apparently switches to consent for behavioral ads

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    Meta announced they will soon switch to "consent" for behavioral ads. Exactly what consequences this will have remains to be seen
    … 100 … Meta apparently switches to consent for behavioral ads after … Kartellamt and decisions by the EDPB and CJEU it seems that Meta finally complies with EU privacy laws. The company … showing behavioral ads in the future. It is uncelar if Meta fully applies the consent requirement. noyb will follow …
  • Norwegian DPA temporarily bans behavioral advertising on Facebook and Instagram

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    The Norwegian DPA is the first national data protection authority declaring behavioral advertising on Meta platforms illegal. noyb welcomes this decision
    … and Instagram Following a CJEU ruling that declared Meta/Facebook’s GDPR approach largely illegal, the Norwegian … imposes a temporary ban for the usage of said approach by Meta. noyb welcomes this decision as a first important step … the Norwegian DPA on the ban of behavioral advertising on Meta platforms CJEU declares Meta/Facebook’s GDPR approach …
  • CJEU declares Meta/Facebook's GDPR approach largely illegal

     / article
    In today's decision, the CJEU declared Meta/Facebook's GDPR approach largely illegal - similar to noyb's previous litigation before the EDPB leading to a fine of € 390 million.
    … million fine Background on the "forced consent" approach by Meta Background on Meta's move to "legitimate interest" First Statement. noyb … From the live reading of the holding, it seems that Meta/Facebook was barred from using anything but consent for …
  • noyb win: First major fine (€ 1 million) for using Google Analytics

     / article  / 
    Data Transfers
    Swedish data protection authority (IMY) issued decisions against four companies and imposed a fine of 12 mio SEK (1 mio Euro) against Tele2 and 300.000 SEK against CDON
    … many EU businesses continue to use services of Google, Meta, Microsoft, Amazon and alike. Many companies however …
  • Ireland: Corrupt GDPR procedures now "confidential"

     / article
    Yesterday, the Irish DPC managed a narrow win in Parliament and got a new law passed that shall make criticism of DPC procedures impossible.
    … will not be available in Ireland anymore. The DPC and Meta have previously threatened lawsuits, but never followed …
  • Irish Gov makes critizising Big Tech and Irish DPC a crime!

     / article  / 
    National Administrative Procedures and DPA inactivity
    The Irish government tries to sneak a provision into the Irish Data Protection Law allowing any part of the procedure being declared "confidential". Legitimate criticism would become a crime.
    … For years the Irish DPC and Big Tech companies like Meta or Google try to sweep GDPR procedures against them … views or act unlawful. Big Tech companies like Google or Meta have previously insisted that all their submissions are …
  • 5 Years of the GDPR: National Authorities let down European Legislator

     / article
    On 25 May 2018, the GDPR came into force; 5 years later, national authorities and courts largely let down the European legislator
    … that could overcome many of the GDPR enforcement issues Meta € 1.2 billion fine is an example of enforcement not … In 2023 alone, nearly €2 billion in fines were imposed on Meta as a result of noyb 's diligent efforts and legal …
  • noyb win: € 1.2 billion fine against Meta over EU-US data transfers

     / article  / 
    Data Transfers
    Facebook must stop further transfers of European personal data to the United States, given that Facebook is subject to US surveillance laws (like FISA 702 and EO 12.333).
    … of the Irish DPC EDPB Decision in the Case Major blow for Meta. Ever since Edward Snowden's revelations on US big tech … aiding the NSA mass surveillance apparatus, Facebook (now Meta) was subject to litigation in Ireland. For ten years, Meta has not taken any material precaution, but simply …
  • No bullsh*t opt-out: free noyb tool for quick and broad Facebook objections!

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    Use the noyb tool to opt out of targeted advertising and various other claimed 'legitimate interestes' by Meta in a simple and legally sound way.
    … Facebook objections is now online! As reported last week , Meta switched the legal basis for targeting advertising from … a yes / no option ("consent") as foreseen by the GDPR, Meta now (unlawfully) claims to have ‘legitimate interest’ … made by M eta in an easy and legally sound way . Object to Meta’s data processing here ! The hidden and complex …
  • Meta (Facebook, Instagram) switching to "Legitimate Interest" for Ads

     / article  / 
    Forced Consent & Consent Bypass
    After noyb complaints, Meta (Facebook and Instagram) is switching form an illegal contract to equally illegal "legitimate interests" for advertisement. noyb will take imminent action.
    … 100 … Meta (Facebook, Instagram) switching to "Legitimate … illegal practice As reported by the Wall Street Journal , Meta (Facebook and Instagram) is switching from an illegal … ("opt-in") for the use of personal data for advertisement, Meta (Facebook and Instagram) has tried to bypass this …
  • Austrian DSB: Meta Tracking Tools Illegal

     / article  / 
    Data Transfers
    Austrian Data Protection Authority (DSB) decided that the use of Facebook’s tracking pixel directly violates the GDPR and the so-called “Schrems II” decision on transatlantic data flows.
    … 88 … Austrian DSB: Meta Tracking Tools Illegal In a groundbreaking decision in … of noyb.eu Illegal Data transfers via Facebook Login and Meta Pixel. The DSBs decision to declare Google Analytics … illegal , also applies to the "Facebook Login" and "Meta Pixel" tools provided by Meta: If these tools are used, …
  • Data Protection Day: Are Europeans really protected?

     / article
    European Data Protection Day commemorates the signing of the first European data protection framework in 1981. Today, the GDPR is meant to enable citizens to exercise their right to privacy.
    … action. It announced a fine of 390 million Euro and ordered Meta to obtain valid consent for personalized advertising . In these 4.5 years, the DPC has often sided with Meta and has now also issued a significantly reduced penalty …