Since 2018, more and more websites have introduced so-called “Pay or Okay” systems for consent requests (e.g. in cookie banners). Instead of giving users a choice to either accept or reject ad tracking, Pay or Okay systems require a payment if people want to refuse this tracking.
The approach was first introduced by newspapers in Austria and Germany, and has now even been adopted by Meta for Instagram and Facebook. By now, many websites across Europe are using similar systems.
This leads to massively inflated consent rates of up to 99.9%, despite the fact that only small minority of people want to be tracked for personalised advertising.
noyb has already filed several complaints against companies using Pay or Okay systems in an effort to ensure that people in the European Union actually have a choice to refuse being tracked online.
| Case | Controller | DPA | Status | Duration |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C045 | Spiegel | HmbBfDI (Hamburg) | Pending (4 years and more) | Filed:
(5 years 3 months ago) |
| C046 | DerStandard | DSB (Austria) | Pending (4 years and more) | Filed:
(5 years 3 months ago) |
| C047 | ZEIT | HmbBfDI (Hamburg) | Partly Won | Filed:
(5 years 3 months ago) |
| C048 | heise | LfDI (Lower Saxony) | Won | Filed:
(5 years 3 months ago) |
| C049 | Krone | DSB (Austria) | Pending (4 years and more) | Filed:
(5 years 3 months ago) |
| C050 | t-online | LDI (North Rhine-Westphalia) | Pending (4 years and more) | Filed:
(5 years 3 months ago) |
| C051 | FAZ | HBDI (Hesse) | Pending (4 years and more) | Filed:
(5 years 3 months ago) |
| C075 | Meta Ireland Limited | DSB (Austria), DPC (Ireland) | Pending (2 - 3 years) | Filed:
(2 years 11 months ago) |
| C076 | Meta Ireland Limited | DSB (Austria), DPC (Ireland) | Pending (2 - 3 years) | Filed:
(2 years 10 months ago) |
| C106 | Schibsted Media AS | Datatilsynet (Norway) | Pending (0 - 6 months) | Filed:
(5 months 1 week ago) |