C029-46 oe24 GmbH

Data Transfers
Case project
Controller
oe24 GmbH
Case status
Pending (4 years and more)
Filed: (4 years 3 months ago)

This is one of noyb 101 complaints which were filed after the "Schrems II" judgement in Summer 2020. The judgement invalidated the EU-US data transfer mechanism "Privacy Shield". The cases were generated based on implemented Google Analytics or Facebook tracking code on websites by EU providers, which leads to unlawful data transfers to the United States.

Protocol
Data Summary
06.03.2023
decision by DSB

upheld against oe24 but rejected against Meta because in the DSB's view only the data exporteur is subject to Chapter V GDPR

18.10.2022
Reply by noyb
27.09.2022
Submission Meta Inc

In reply to our submission and that of oe24. Nothing substantially new, 3 weeks deadline to reply.

27.09.2022
Statement by Meta Inc

Not really new arguments

22.08.2022
Notification by DSB

DSB will hear Meta and oe24 on our submissions and then intends to issue a decision.

25.07.2022
Submission noyb

... on Meta's last submission

13.07.2022
noyb asked DSB to provide us with Meta Incs submission of November 2022

noyb asked DSB to provide us with Meta Inc's submission of 11.03.2022, which we had not been provided with yet but which is mentioned in the minutes of the interrogation. On the same day, the DSB provided us with this submission.

27.06.2022
DSB sent us the minutes of the interogation of Facebook Inc

DSB sent us the minutes of the interrogation and gave us a 4 week deadline to give a statement.

01.06.2022
noyb sopke to DSB on the phone

After we learned about an oral hearing with the DSB and FB noyb spoke to the DSB on the phone in that matter. The case manager explained that there had been no oral hearing but that he has only interrogation and we will be provided with the protocol.

21.05.2022
noyb met with the controller upon their request

General update on situation, no procedural relevance.

21.02.2022
DSB replied that the investigation is ongoing
17.02.2022
npyb asked the DSB for an update
24.09.2021
noyb filed the requested submission
04.08.2021
DSB granted the extension of the deadline

DSB granted the extension of the deadline. New deadline: 24.09.2021.

03.08.2021
noyb sent an email to the DSB asking for a 3 week extension of the deadline

as their submissions are extensive and contain a lot of untrue or distracting statements that need to be countered

30.07.2021
DSB sent us several statements by Facebook

DSB sent us several statements by and correspondence with FB Inc and set a 5 week deadline for us to reply. Facebook has been trying to ensure that we do not get to see their submissions because they are "confidential". Without success.

11.05.2021
DSB gave us access to the case file

DSB gave us access to the file. They also set a 2 week deadline for FB Inc to give a statement.

10.05.2021
noyb submitted a statement to the DSB

noyb submitted our statement to the DSB stating that FB Inc is a party to the procedure and that the DSB is competent for them under Article 55 GDPR. Also, we requested access to the file.

06.05.2021
DSB informed us that they are still in exchange with Facebook

DSB informed us that they had asked FB Inc for a statement. FB Inc had replied that FB Ireland is responsible for the processing, so the DSB had forwarded their questions to FB Ireland, which in turn stated that only the DPC would be competent for them.

26.02.2021
DSB informed us that they have asked Facbeook for a statement

DSB informed us, that they have asked FB for a statement on the use of FB Tools. Deadline for FB: 3 weeks.

22.01.2021
We submitted our reply to the DSB
07.01.2021
DSB sent us oe24s reply and gave us 5 weeks to reply
16.12.2020
noyb replied to the lawyers of of oe24 that contacted us asking to withdraw the complaint

We will not withdraw.

16.12.2020
Received a message from the lawyers oe24

Received a ticket from the lawyers of oe24 stating that immediately after receiving the complaint, they removed all Facebook tools. noyb checked this on Dec. 16 and this is true, there is no sign of Facebook cookies anymore. However, the company still uses a multitude of cookies causing unlawful data transfers.

06.10.2020
DSB stayed procedure until LSA is established and has decided
17.08.2020
Complaint